When you lap ferrules are you lubricating them? No. You are checking your fit dry.
Yes, a lubricant is used while lapping a ferrule to fit. The next time you lap a #30 ferrule let us know how well it works out without using some lubricant to check the fit.
You probably include ferrule plugs to keep the dirt out, don’t you?
Yes, a ferrule plug is provided however, on my rods it is not to keep the female clean albeit a benefit, but to protect the tip sections from the rubber butt cap on the butt end of the rod.
You mentioned that ferrules need to be kept clean twice above. How often do folks actually clean the female ferrule? Is there going to be dirt in there? Of course there is.
I stand by the statement that ferrules need to be kept clean and lubricated. Once a rod leaves the shop rodmakers have no control over how the customer takes care of their rods. I don’t know how often the customer cleans their ferrules and neither do you.
You are completely missing the point. DIRT is the enemy, not the wax. Ferrules stick because of DIRT. Ferrules get loose because of DIRT wearing them down. Dirt and dust stick to wax and oil. There will be less dirt if you do not put anything on the the ferrule for dirt to stick to.
Missing the point? Whatever.
Ferrules stick because a metal-to-metal fit tends to gall. Weather the galling is caused by dirt or surface finish is of no consequence once the ferrule is stuck. A high pressure lubricant fills the surface roughness and separates the metal surfaces from each other allowing for a smooth sliding fit.
The problem is that 90% of the people that wax a ferrule, graphite or metal, never clean the danged thing. Most of them never think to clean the ferrule after it sticks. No, they try to free it by twisting and break or otherwise damage the rod.
So what? The fact people don’t follow instructions does not change the fact that ferrules should be lubricated. I suspect your 90% figure is not based on fact but is merely conjecture.
How much dirt is already in the oil you use from the side of your nose? You washed your face? OK, what about the dust devil you walked through getting to the stream? How about the dust you might kick up on the path or trail getting there? Some of that stuck to the oil on your nose and you just put dirt on your ferrules that will cause more wear.
You didn’t get this oil from the side of the nose from me. I don’t recommend the practice.
Keeping a ferrule clean means more than just wiping off the male side. You have to clean the dirt impregnated wax and oil out of the female side, too. Ferrule plugs will certainly help keep dirt out, but they do nothing for the dirt and oil that is transferred by oiling or waxing a male ferrule. Since it is near impossible to get people to clean things, adding a dirt trapping material to a ferrule is just plain silly.
Running ferrules dry is the silly practice.
This is simple common sense, guys, not rocket science.
You are right, it is not rocket science. Keep ferrules clean and lubricated. People can choose to not clean their ferrules or to clean their ferrules. It is their choice. It is still a free country. Does not change the requirement for a ferrule to be clean and lightly lubricated.
fishbum