You didn’t specify the length of your rods. That might influence some suggestions. I recently finished a small rod, 6’6" 2 weight. Wanted it for some small creeks I might fish. Really like it and I can get a long, by my standards, cast out there when I need to.
I guess one of the things I am hoping to find out is the functional difference between a “moderate action” rod and a “fast action” rod. Perhaps if I better understood the specific fishing applications of each I would be in a better position to know which best fits the environments I fish.
From the limit material I have reviewed I get the impression that the fast action is better in windy conditions???
Longer Casts - A fast action fly rod is ideal where the angler needs to make consistently long casts.
Landing Large Fish - A fast action fly rod makes it much easier, and quicker, to land very large fish.
Windy Conditions - Due to the high line speed generated by fast action fly rods, casting in windy conditions is much easier and more effective using a fast action fly rod - especially if used in conjunction with advanced casting techniques that help reduce some of the effect of wind resistance.
Quick Casts - The stiffness of fast action fly rods allow for very quick casts - something that is often appreciated by advanced anglers since more casts allow for more potential fish to be caught.
“Advantages of Fast Action Fly Rods” - According to who?
“Longer Casts - A fast action fly rod is ideal where the angler needs to make consistently long casts.” - Define ‘long’ and does this take into account roll-casting?
“Landing Large Fish - A fast action fly rod makes it much easier, and quicker, to land very large fish.” - It’s also more likely for a good trout to break off from a fast action rod. This depends on the technique(s) used by the fisherman.
“Windy Conditions - Due to the high line speed generated by fast action fly rods, casting in windy conditions is much easier and more effective using a fast action fly rod - especially if used in conjunction with advanced casting techniques that help reduce some of the effect of wind resistance.”- While I generall agree with that comment,distance of the cast required is important and may negate the advantage of a fast action rod.
“Quick Casts - The stiffness of fast action fly rods allow for very quick casts - something that is often appreciated by advanced anglers since more casts allow for more potential fish to be caught.” - Not sure if this is true.
“SO now do you consider am IM7 fast???” - I think ‘fast’ is in the eye of the individual caster. What I consider fast may be different from what a professional caster would typically say is fast which may be different from what you would consider fast. My point is that you should be comfortable casting a rod regardless of how it is labeled by the manufacturer. Also,there are ways of increasing the ‘fastness’ of a rod if you’re building it. The number of guides and guide spacing are two ways to alter the speed of a rod. Another is overlining or underlining.
These are just some thoughts and you should consider the water and the fish you’re after as well as the general conditions you’ll be facing.
I was used to fishing the Sage XP rods which I guess would be considered fast for that generation of graphite. Sage now has much faster blanks.
My first build was an IM6 that I just can’t stand – it came out ok but so slow compared to the XP that I usually fish with. I can’t stand the IM6 but that is just my preference. I’ll probably leave it out somewhere so it looks like I forgot it and some (un)lucky guy can find it and call it his own.
For the second rod I went looking for something faster - like the XP - but I didn’t want to pay for the high end Sage Rods (or similar brand names). I was ready to buy the Batson RX8+ which is considered very fast; however, they don’t sell direct. I went to a supplier named Dan Craft Enterprises in West Fir, Oregon. While speaking to him, he said he had a very fast blank that he has made (Fiver Rivers Series) and I decided to try it – and I am very glad I did. The rod is light and lightening fast and fund to cast. I now use it almost exclusively and the Sage stays in the tube. The price was also very reasonable and Dan Crafts service was also very good.
I think it is difficult to really determine what to get and how fast it will be. I don’t have access to different blanks to try out before buying so I have to take a shot in the dark. Especially if not buying one of the brand blanks.
I know that everyone looks down on the term modulus and would prefer to evaluate taper; however, I haven’t seen much in catalogs on taper and I wouldn’t really know what it means. Whereas modulus is at least something that I can kind of relate to. Also, terms like fast, medium fast, slow, etc. are all relative to someone elses perception - in my opinion.
Whatever you decide, have fun and good luck. This is a great site for getting advice and some of those responding have been very helpful to me.
Since I live in Muskegon, Michigan I have decided to attempt some streamer fishing on the Muskegon River therefore I selected a 9 ft. ?moderate/fast? action 6wt. IM7 rod for my next project. Supposedly this rod will also be adequate for Bass fishing should I be inclined at some point in the future.