It really depends on when you ask me. The only thing that does remain consistent is that they are separated by type, color, and space permitting, size.
Right now I have terrestrials and midges separated from my other dry flies. The midges are in a very small box that fits in one of my upper vest pockets.
Sometimes I’ll pick a small selection of these flies for a certain fishing location, and put them all into one palm sized box.
This could all change, however, the next time I get bored and have a little time on my hands.
I have struggled with this same question. Here is a solution that works well for me…
I use 2 kinds of boxes, large ones for bulk storage and small ones for stream side. The big boxes organize my flies for easy tying and inventory. The small boxes are for fishing.
The large boxes are (10"X16") single compartment Plano boxes with a foam ripple on both the box and the lid. I can easily get over 1000 flies each box. I organize the flies to facilitate my tying and access, it’s my home equivelent of the big display cabinets at the fly shop.
For example, my mayfly box has all of the may fly patterns I like to tie. I neatly stick the flies into the foam in patches sorted by size, color and quantity, one row of dark BWO size 18, then a row of size 20, etc. I can take the box to my bench and quickly see what I need to tie to replace lost flies. Three of the big boxes fit neatly into a soft side nylon briefcase and get tossed into the back of the car for road trips.
The small boxes are pocket sized and are organized for specific fishing trips.
They get filled or emptied as the seasons or my destinations change. I select the bugs I am most likely to use in a days fishing on a particular river or a specific hatch.
For example, in the spring I put togehter a BWO box, with nymphs, emergers and adults. I might put a second ‘dry and dropper’ box together with big floating drys and tiny nymphs and scuds. A third box might be ‘grab bag’ mix of attractors, hoppers, ants and other once in a while bugs.
I TRY to keep my dry flies seperated into 3 basic groups: Mayflies, Caddis, Attractors (includes ant, beetles, hoppers). I also keep them seperated by pattern, and if I have a lot of one pattern (BWO’s for instance), I seperate by size as well.
All of my fies are by pattern and size. All the same pattern in a row and all of the sizes of those patterns are in there own compartment on the dry’s The Nymphs are done the same way. I am talking about flies that are used for specific hatches. All attractor types of patterns are to size and to pattern in a row. Same with all of my flies. When I start to run out I will tie more and fill her up. I normally tie 6 to a dozen of each pattern and size for a given fly. Sometimes more when it is a pattern I know I will be using a lot of.
I came up with a nymph pattern last year that worked real well on the Yellowstone and tied up 3 1/2 dozen in 5 sizes this year. I am about half way through them and I have only been able to fish twice this year so far. But my son and his friend sure likes them LOL.
By keeping your flies in order you will be able to tell which one’s are working the best in a given year and which you need to replace at a glance. Ron
I set up my organization by type of fly and by color/sizes. If I have only a few of one size, I will usually combine them. My nymphs are another story. I have a big box that I cut down foam. They stacked in little neat rows according to type of nymph and sizing down from there. They look like a naval blockade at the end of a winter’s tying.
RonMT,
Interested in becoming famous, at least on FAOL? Any chance you might divulge the recipe for the new nymph you mentioned? I use Craig Mathews patterns in northern Michigan to good advantage. Chances are good that your nymph will also be effective here.
If you’re not interested, no problem. I carry too many patterns already. I admire JCs shirtpocket tackle box.