Diane,
How you look at a fly tying vise depends a lot on how much you tie AND how much you enjoy good tools, fun gadgts, and just having ‘neat’ stuff.
A plain old Thompson model A or any of the decent quality vises of it’s ilk will last even a frenetic tyer for a lifetime. A pair of vise grips and a c-clamp will work too.
However, if you really enjoy having neat things, you can get vises with lots of ‘frills’. Fun gadgets, cool accessories. Stuff that makes some operations more efficient or just easier.
I tied litterally thousands of flies on a vise I paid $19.99 for from a mail order house. Worked okay, but was very ‘basic’, and I began to want something ‘better’.
I spend several hours about five or six nights a week tying flies for the fun and relaxation of it. I fish with some of them, give lots away, and trade some to my local fly shop for stuff that I can’t make myself. I really like fly tying and expect to be doing it for several more decades.
Looking at it logically, from my own perspective, I could get a vise a ‘little’ better than I had that will work for a time, then upgrade again later on. Or, I could save my money until I could buy a top of the line vise that would do everything I’d ever need to do at the bench. My intention would be to buy ‘one’, and get it for the rest of my life.
I like cool tools, like learning to get the most from them, so I had a vise built for me, exactly the way I wanted it, from DynaKing. Cost a lot. I’ll never buy another vise. Can’t ‘recommend’ that kind of expense to anyone else, though. It’s a personal choice.
I’m happy with my vise. I’d have probably been happy with a less expensive one, too. That part I’ll never know, but I also don’t regret the expenditure one little bit.
Also can’t claim that my flies are any better because of the ‘vise’. I do know that they have become better from the ‘practice’, though.
Good luck!
Buddy