I am interested in the responses you may receive on this topic. I been talking about running the experiement with treated and untreated flies, but once I get tying, I don’t get around treating any flies.
I’ve been using flies treated with “Watershed” this year. You just apply and wait at least 24 hours for the stuff to dry. While fishing [or after catching a fish] just false cast 2 or 3 times and you’re good to go with a floating dry fly. No odor that I can detect [after they dry; there is an odor when you first apply the stuff].
So far this stuff has worked well. I also tie with the artifical dubbing that “doesn’t soak up water”.
Buddy,
I started a thread a couple of months ago about this that turned into a fight about why anybody would not use products that were “made” for fly fishing versus trying something different and new AND might work better. I have used Hydrostop and Watershed before and were not satisfied with their results. Rain-X was suggested and it works very well, much better than those other two products. I bought some silicone waterproofing liquid that was recommended in one of this site’s Tying Tips, but haven’t had the opportunity to test it yet. I will next week. Thompson’s Water Seal had been suggested for years by tiers. I tried it and it discolored some materials and stayed oily. However, after I dried and blotted the flies with a cloth it floated them like a champ. Too much work for me, though.
Joe
I keep a small tupperware container my wife got at a party on my table with a small amount of RainX in it. It’s small, maybe 2" across and 1 1/2" deep. After tying a fly I put it in there and shake it a couple times and then hang it to dry. Never been disappointed yet.
silocon spray. Tie the flies, stick to a stick and spray them. Let dry overnight and you are done. I usually have to replace the fly cause it is chewed up rather than cause it doesnt float.
Just a word of caution when using Rain-X. Last spring I tied up some parasol flies and used Rain-X to treat the parasols. The parasols were tied on using tippet materiel. Several days later when I went to the stream to fish with them, the tippet materiel had dissolved. The flies them selves were OK, but all the tippet materiel was gone. So, if your using a mono type thread do not treat your flies with Rain-X. BTW I’ve used this product for several years and have never had any problems except this one.