If there’s anything I know less about than salmon flies (and at least I have caught salmon, albeit hatchery kings from the Salmon River in NY) it’s sea-run cutthroat flies, but I do know pretty and the Borden Special is a pretty fly; maybe not this one so much.
I’ve had some luck with similar flies, especially Comets, but most of the shad fishing I do is on the Potomac in deep water/strong current and I usually have to use something heavier, even with a Teeny T250 line. My go-to “flies” have been 1/16 oz crappie jigs with Mr. Twister tails, a real joy to cast, especially when the wind is up.
Skykomish Yellow (didn’t have any red chenille for a Skykomish Sunrise)
Tied the wing with the Ed Haas method Allan described in the Coal Car sbs - facing forward over the eye of the hook, then folded back; locks the hair in place.
I think these look fantastic! I bet they would work for a number of species… looking at the colors here, my first thought was swinging them for white bass.
Scott I fish the lower Delaware (big water) average depth 40 feet and over 150 yds. wide. I use different heads made from Cortland lead core and Cortland braided mono and have no problem getting those flies down. no need for jig style flies then. I use an 8 wt. rod most times.
Problem is, a majority of the shad we see are the smaller hickories; an 8wt would be a bit much for them. I’ll see what I can do with some LC13 I have; I could also add some non-tox wire to the hook shank to start the flies…