I tried this several months ago. Recently, I find that Craig Mathews has been tying these (for who knows how long) and has named it “Improved Sparkle Dun”. I like this because it gives a more stable wingset. Size 16 fly.
Very trim, very neat; well done, as always. I tie mine on an emerger hook (Dai Riki 125) but may have to try some on a dry hook. You using a Dai Riki 305?
Craig also skipped the dubbed abdomen and just used the tying thread. On early versions, he also incorporated a quail body feather into the shuck, but seems to have omitted that now.
Scott. Not sure I understand the second youtube linked pattern. Why is the wing tied so far back from the hook eye. Take a look and let me know what I’m missing.
Thanks,
Byron