The starling and peacock is a favorite fly of mine. Insterad of using a wire core that the herl is wrapped on, I just wrap the herl around my tying thread while it’s at the rear of the hook. Then wrap the thread/herl combination forward. I get a sturdier fly, like yours, without tying in and using the wire. Just a step saver to me, or are you using the wire as added weight for the fly?
This is a really effective fly when there are Grannoms about, especially if they are fished in or near the surface film. The Leisenring Lift method of fishing them works well too.
Ron,
I did put both methods on the blog site. When I’m using a wire core, I tend to not use any additional weight (yes, the wire does add just a bit of weight).
The second group of photos on the blog site showed me usine a “thread loop” and wrapping the hurl around the thread loop.
Like you, I fish this fly in the surface film, but I also will fish it in warm water down off a popper and in that way, I add some weight to get it hanging down more.
Thanks for the comments. It is a very effective fly for me. Glad I’m not the only one who uses it.
Is this the fly? I couldn’t tell from the blog …I made a couple recently…they were called Starling and Herl, at least in the recipe I looked at…it looks like a bang up fly…the picture didn’t do it justice
Yes, that is the fly. I know my photos are not that great (need a better camera). Life’s far too short to worry too much about how pretty a fly is anyway. The fish don’t care and as many as I hang in trees, stumps, rocks and other snags I don’t want to be crying over a lost fly. I’ve always believed presentation is much more important than if a fly is pretty. I wasn’t too sure how to read your post so thought a little explaination may help.
The fly can be tied any number of ways. Sometimes, I do put a tail on it with a couple hen cape barbules, and sometimes, I use a gold wire to hold everything together and add just a touch of weight (see discussion with REE above).
But your photo below is the fly and you obviously have a much better camera than I do. This fly is a fish catcher. I checked out some of the other flies on your photobucket site. You do tie nice looking flies.
A variant (in the blog post) is to tie in your starling feather at the hook bend and palmer it all the way to the hook eye. That is not a traditional soft hackle, but it sure does look “buggy” and it has brought a lot of fish to my net.
I tie them both ways. If a person wants to make it look just like ones in a book or spend time making it pretty, cool. I love to look at pictures of pretty flies and enjoy it when FAOLers post them for us all to see.