Catoctin Mountain region, MD

Anticipating our first real snowfall this year, I headed west and fished a small stream located about 10 miles north of Frederick, MD to catch a few brookies. The day started out slowly, as air temps were barely 20 degrees and water temp was about 37. Got on the water about 9:30 AM with a buddy, caught a half-dozen between the two of us and lost a few more. Only one fish hit the indicator, a good sign that going subsurface was the right thing to do. Around 12:30, my friend left, and I headed upstream in search of some fresh spots. I’d never been upstream of where we stopped shortly after noon…

Turned out to be one beautiful plunge pool after another, each one yielding a fish or two (or five, in one case). Ended up releasing over 2 dozen, most of which were around 4 inches, a few pushing 6. Most fish took #14-#18 BH PTs tied on scud hooks, while a few took green weenies in various sizes and configurations. Some really nice fish, despite the cold.

Started snowing around 1 PM, coated everything but the water. What a treat! Drove home around 3, sadly to see many cars off the road around Frederick. Icy conditions all over…made it home to Baltimore in one piece. And watched football the rest of the day…

Marty

MFTG,
Thanks for your report! It looks like you had a great time!
Doug :smiley:

Marty,
10 miles north…hum…not quite to Thurmont…First stretch of water that Matt and I hooked into wild brookies. Don’t know how far you went up or which branch, but always fish. Fella that used to own the last store/greasy spoon before heading up into the hills used to serve up some dynamite bar-b-que, I envy your opportunities to get out. They ain’t big, but they fight like they are monsters!
Cheers,
Mike K.

Mike,

I distinctly remember the story that you and Matt told me about that place. I fished the “west” branch yesterday, but about 2 months ago I had a whole day and fished both of them. I fancy myself the brookie whisperer these days (which couldn’t be farther from the truth!!!), and heeded your advice about that stream system. I should have thanked you and Matt in the original post!

You know, it’s amazing that I had been to that park twice before I ever fished it - rock climbing, before I got bit real bad by the fishin’ bug. I fished the main branch pretty far up, it has to be one of the prettiest places in this area and since you can’t get up there as often, I’ll fish it for you! Sound like a deal? Next time you guys are up, we should take a trip out there and have a brookie bash!

Take care, and I owe you for turning me onto the stream - I just recalled that you spoke highly of it, though I had no idea where it was. I’ll PM you with some additional info…

Marty

MFTG keep the reports comeing, all I can do is live vicariously through you all that are lucky enough to live in the lower 48 where it is warm right now and rivers not frozen.
Looks like you had a great day Char are Beutiful fish

Is a cool little stream. The club stock rainbows in there too and youll get one every once in a while. Ive seen fish rising in that reservoir also, I wish it were fishable.

Nice.

Right up the road from me … you’re killing me! :wink:

That’s OK. I was working and I’ll bet I had as much fun with my laptop and paperwork, as you had with your rod and those brookies. :roll:

Good to see someone got out!

Dave

Dave,

PM me if you get some time to hit the streams. Always glad to meet up with a fellow addict.

MikeL,

I know the DNR stocks rainbows in both the upper and lower sections of the creek, the put-and-take notices are all over the place! Last time I was out there I saw a few rainbows that were left over from the October stocking, but didn’t trick any into a take. There are a few fair-sized brookies in there, but I think there are bigger fish (albeit fewer) in BHC.

Marty

A buddy got a 14" brookie in there. I kid you not. He thinks it came up from the reservoir. :slight_smile:

In BHC or in F Creek? I spooked a nice fish in Little F when I was there in early December. Don’t know if it was a stocked rainbow that went up there, or a brookie. I DOUBT many rainbows make it up very far in Little F - the fish I saw was about 1/2 mile up from the confluence.

Dang, 14"? Guess I know where I’ll be going next weekend :lol:

Let me know if you have any interest in poking around out there. I know there’s another nice stream out that way, lots of brookies, never fished it (Little T.).

Marty

North Umpqua steelhead fly fishing conditions are just about perfect right now. It’s a little bit colder in the morning than I like it but I’m not far from the fishing so I can wait till noon and still have a good day of fly fishing. Anyone in the area interested in checking it out, let me know. Neoprenes and wading staffs a must !

Cheers,

MontanaMoose

Oops…din’t mean to post that here !

You forgot to mention cleats. That polished rock is the most slippery stuff I have set foot on, including ice.

Marty

MFTG
Nice little fish. Good to know that I am actually missing something each time I tell myself its not worth going out. You ever fished F Creek (assuming I know which one were talking about). I drive over it everyday and never really gave it much attention. I figured something with so obvious a name must be over fished.

Where it goes under 15 is the lower creek, not much doing there except for stocked bows. If you go west on Mountaindale, follow Mountaindale up past the lake, it becomes your typical high-gradient plunge pool mountain stream, that’s where the brookies are. It’s a dirt road up above the lake, and it splits so you can drive up (upper) F Creek or Little F.

I hate to look like such a jerk, not naming it, but this place just can’t take a lot of fishing pressure.

PM me if ya like!

Marty

MFTG,

I’m familiar with the area you are refering to. I don’t blame you for not naming it. In fact, I’m glad that no one has said it so far.

I call it a “skunk hole”. Not because it’s a bad place … because I come home with the smell of skunk on me. :lol:

Dave

Ha! Try fishing a beadhead PT nymph under a small indicator, works like a charm.

Marty

Marty,

Thanks for the tip! I’ll try it next time.

Thanks.

Dave.

Dave,
I usually have good responses from Elk hair caddis or even a Renegade…sizes vary, but those critters are agressive. Last time Matt and I were up water was REAL low. The smaller of the two we passed up just so as not to stress the fish any more than necessary. The larger one looked like a tornadoe had walked through.

Did score some 12 - 14" Brookies up on BHC - stockies, but last I checked they were still fish. Most of the natives out of those creeks won’t make that size. They are still beautiful creatures!

Cheerios,
Mike K.

Caught this little guy while pounding that stream with my stealthy fly tackle. BTW: Beautiful countryside up there!