I guess that everybody is different in regards to which gloves are best for them. For me, it doesn't matter which type of fingerless gloves I wear, because with exposed fingertips my hands are always as cold as not wearing any gloves at all. As a result, I found that an inexpensive lightweight polar fleece glove works best for me. Even when I get it wet, I simply ring it out and continue to wear it, and it still keeps my hands warmer then if I were wearing fingerless gloves.