You are the one who has to define "Best" it may be the best buy but not the top performer. I have noticed that some people don't let price become an object, I think some of these are guides and using equipment almost daily make quality all the more important. Until I make my second million, I have to watch price and I mainly fish when it please me and the weather is decent.

I love my Fishcat LCS 4, it is frameless mini pontoon and weighs about the same as my round tube. That said it cost quite a bit more than my Caddis round tube which has been pretty much trouble free.