I never had a short rod until this summer, when I was given a 7'6". I happened to have a sore rotator cuff, so decided to try it to see if it would be any better than the 9' and it was decidedly easier on my shoulder, and I fished the Bighorn with it very successfully, and didn't see any difference in the way it mended. I also used my bamboo "banty" at 6' and thoroughly enjoyed it. I think it all amounts to the feel that you like, and each rod has a different personality.