Yeah, Aquaseal is awesome. I tend to go on patching sprees, so a tube only lasting a couple months is OK for me.

Good idea on filling them. They only leaking at depths over 2' and only when I'm wearing them. At first, I stood in a kitchen trash can full of water and found a few small holes around the seams (there isn't just one hole). I think I managed to get all those, but there seems to be one left somewhere higher on the bootie.

I think I'll look into calling Cabela's--is 4 years too long? I wouldn't ordinarily do it but I hardly used them until the last year and they look pretty much new. They should've taken more use.

Dry Plus Wet--funny. I guess I got what I paid for then!