I've got the deep wading jacket and like it very well. It does come up short in some ways though.

Strengths: Packs small enough to fit well in the back of a vest, ideal length to wear with waders, good hood design, HUGE chest pockets, water resistant cuffs, totally waterproof, and breathes well.

Shortcomings: Bottom hits about my belly-button and would leave a gap between rain pants and jacket, lighter material not the toughest out there, and not Gore-Tex, so don't let the Deet hit it.

I think its ideal for wearing with waders or for some core warmth when wading wet, but I wouldn't like it when wearing waterproof pants. Just so you know, mine is a XXL, and I am 5'10" and about 250, with most of the girth around my chest rather than waist, slowly changing to the opposite as the years go by.