Our Man In Canada
September 18th, 2000

Between the Leaves

By Chris Marshall


Fumbling With a Fly Rod: Stories from the River
By Ian Colin James. HarperCollins, 55 Avenue Rd.,
Suite 2900, Toronto, ON
M5R 3L2, 2000.
205 pages, hardbound. $27.00
ISBN 0-00-200042-3

First of all, I have to admit that time constraints frequently force me to skim the pages when I'm reading books for review. This was impossible with Fumbling With a Fly Rod. It seduced me into spending a whole afternoon of reading the whole thing when I'd a thousand other things to do.

Ian James' collection of twelve "stories from the river" is a book out of time, because, rather than concentrate on the hard facts of where, how, and when to fish, it celebrates the experience of fly fishing - something we've seen too little of in the last half century. It recreates those moments - comic, tragic, pastoral - which are the elan vital of fly fishing. Not that the book lacks information - far from it- it's packed with pointers on fishing techniques, fly patterns and, particularly, streamcraft - the stuff of 34 years of observant and intelligent fly fishing.

Most of the stories feature some degree of disaster, particularly involving falling in the river, breaking rods, and embarrassing defeats by large fish. In some of these, such as his account of falling into the Niagara River just below the falls, James flirts with tragedy, but skillfully shifts into high comedy.

James is also a master of dissembling - an incorrigible and accomplished liar - in the cause of deflecting potentially destructive "anglers" away from his quiet places on the river. He delights in assuming the persona of ignoramus in his encounters with these. He's equally ruthless with "poseurs". One of my favourite moments in the book, is his account of meeting a couple of spandex-clad, yuppie trail bikers in the parking lot after an exhilarating and successful day on the river during a succession of thunderstorms. He's soaked, disheveled and magnificently disreputable. Here's how he describes the encounter:

"Did you get anything?" one of the cyclists inquires.

"Nah. A few rock bass."

"I've been fly fishing since the spring," he said, checking the spokes on a wheel.

"Oh yeah, in here?" I asked, breaking down my fly rod, hoping he might reveal a spot I'd never fished before.

"No, I go to Shellie's Trout Ponds and Sweetpeas Produce on the fifth concession.

"You get a few, do you?" I was disappointed, but it's always worth a try.

"Tons. There's nothing to fly-fishing. It's really simple."

"Yeah, so they tell me. I've only been at it for a week or two. I guess it's like riding a bike," I said.

After activating all their high-tech gadgets to protect their vehicle, the yuppies ride off, advising James to "stick with it, you'll get the hang of it". The irony is delightful.

But what delights me most about Fumbling With a Flyrod is James' ability to recreate the experience of being on the river. His keen observation embraces not just the water and the fish, but also leaves of bankside vegetation gleaming in sunshine after rain, the flight of insects, the chatter of birds, the rumble of distant thunder, and the mist cloaking the water at dawn.

This is a book which appeals to a much wider audience than just fly fishers. It's not surprising that it made the Canadian best-seller list in May - only weeks after coming off-press.


Fly Fishing for Great Lakes Steelhead By Rick Kustich and Jerry Kustich. West River Publishing,
P.O. Box 15, Grand Island, NY 14072, 1999
280 pages, colour and half-tone photography, map.
Hardbound. $39.95 (US)
ISBN 0-9633109-1-7

Although the authors of Fly Fishing for Great Lakes Steelhead are not Canadian, a number of Canadian fly fishers have made significant contributions, from fly patterns by a number of well-known Ontario tyers and steelheaders to superb drawings by Al Hassall. The authors also provide profiles of 13 Ontario steelhead rivers.

The book is divided into three sections: The Fishery, The Fly Fishing Approach and A Guide to the Rivers. The first section, which covers over 80 pages, examines the background and history of steelhead in the Great Lakes region. Emphasising the importance of careful and intelligent management of wild stocks of fish, it sets the tone for the whole book.

The second section covering steelhead behaviour, reading the water, strategies, and flies, provides a wealth of information. I was particularly interested in the section on fishing dry flies - a technique only just being explored on Great Lakes tributaries. There are eight full-colour plates of 135 flies and recipes for each of them.

The final section is a collection of profiles on 33 specific rivers (13 of them Canadian). Besides giving tips on how and when to fish, the authors bring each river delightfully to life with anecdotes of times spent fishing on them.

Fly Fishing for Great Lakes Steelhead was five years in the making, but the experience it embodies derives from decades of observing and fishing the region. This is an impressive work - thorough, intelligent, and unique. It is essential for any Great Lakes fly fisher who takes steelheading seriously.


Fly Fishing the Grand River
By Ian D. Martin and Jane E. Rutherford.
The Usual Press,
RR #2, Elora, Ontario, 1995
64 pages, black & white drawings, eight colour plates of flies, two hatch charts.
Spiral bound $20.00

First published in 1996, Fly Fishing the Grand River has just entered its fourth printing. This is an indication of the tremendous popularity of this "little" book, which manages to pack so much in its 64 pages. The title is something of a misnomer, as the authors deliver more than just how to fish the Grand. For the book is really about hatches and how to fish them throughout Southern Ontario. Sure, the main focus is on the Grand, but on most rivers in the region the same flies hatch at more or less the same time, and the same techniques for imitating and fishing them are equally applicable.

Current Issue Canadian Fly fisher

Each author holds a Ph.D. in the ecology and behaviour of stream insects - and it shows. The information on aquatic insects and how to tie and fish flies is detailed and authoritative. The sections on caddis flies are particularly impressive.

Fly fishers in Southern Ontario should make sure they have a copy in their vest pockets. ~ Chris Marshall

We thank the Canadian Fly Fisher for re-print permission!

Our Man In Canada Archives

[ HOME ]

[ Search ] [ Contact FAOL ] [ Media Kit ]

FlyAnglersOnline.com © Notice