I tie flies to catch fish period, and it has been my experience that flies tied that are scruffy and disheveled looking produce more hits and catch more fish. It's common knowledge that lions and other large predators look for the prey that stands out from the rest, the ones that have something wrong with them. They are easier to catch which saves energy and reduce the liklihood of being injured during the hunt. There is no reason for me to think that it doesn't work in a very similar manner for fish. The wounded, crippeld or damaged prey is easier to catch and for a fish it is a simple equation (expend the least amount of energy for maximum return). That's also why large flies oftern catch fewer, but larger fish. Just the experience of a relatively young 72 year old who tries to pay attention.

Jim Smith