Joel;
There is a lot of great trout fishing in the area and you are only about 60 miles from the "Holy Waters" of the Au Sable River.
The Non-Resident license is $30.00 for 3 days and 76for the year. You are close enough that you may want to consider the yearly license.
That time of year will be small fly's. Check out the hatch chart at Gate's Lodge for a better selection.
I just spent a night in Indy on my way to the Michigan Fish-In!! I bet I could have mooched a free dinner off you in exchange for info on trout fishing in Michigan!!
Make a note to attend the Michigan Fish-In next year.