Keep the CD. It has much better drag than the Crosswater and the machined aluminum construction will be more durable over the long haul. The Crosswater is a pretty good reel for the money. The CD cost about 4 times as much so you would expect it to be better.

Th CD 9/10 is a pretty good reel for 6 through 10 wt lines. The CD hasnt been made for a few years as it was replaced by the Rise in Redington's line up, so you might have to hunt for spools.