I too searched for something to replace my vest which just became uncomfortable. After much trial and error I decided on the orivs safe passage hip pack (all the major companies make something very similar, orvis, simms, fishpond, ll bean). With a lanyard and regular fishing shirt (with big front pockets). I was good to go. Spent a whole bunch of time the last week (in both rain and hear) or so with this set up and was much happier than a vest.