Hi Derik;
I'm a little south of you, I troll very little, but I have a lot of friends that I tie for. They fish Sebago mostly and some Moosehead. I'll give you what they always ask for in the most popular to least popular. Hope this helps you.
Arnold
King Smelt
Govenor Aiken
Nine Three
Black Ghost
Mickey Finn
Sneaker
When I tie these I tie the rear hook up, and always paint eyes on them. And it appears #4 Mustad 9672 is the ticket.
Good luck fishing and have fun.