I have used most of the glove types mentioned here and my best solution is a combination of items. Either the fingerless wool or fleece gloves with a Surgical glove underneath has been the best for me. Sometimes when starting out in the morning it's really cold and then warms some. In those type conditions i'll remove the fingerless glove and just wear the surgical glove. It keeps the wind and wet off but allows great dexterity. The surgical gloves can be purchased by the box full, which is good because they usually are full of holes after a good day releasing fish. Try em i think you'll be surprised. RC
P.S. I tried those dishwashing gloves too but water seems to get into them too easily.