My wife and I stayed at Chez Pierre on LI in 2004.We loved it...the food was outrageously good & the husband and wife team that ran the place were very accommodating.

If you or your wife are higher maintenance,you may not be happy with the acommodations:a little beach hut-comfy bed.Good screens-with the waves gently lapping at your doorstep 90 yds away.VERY ROMANTIC,even for an old phart like me.

Rent a car--see the island--go to Deadman's Cay.Hire a guide out of Deadman's Cay
Don't use the guide Chez Pierre suggest,if he's still there ..lazy as sin..probably got fired by now

If you hit it right LI is the best place in the Bahamas for large #s of bones.
I've fished the Bahamas since the late 70's and LI and South Andros are my favoites.

PM me for more info