I prefer fingerless wool gloves, preferably with thinsulate insulation in them. When it is really cold, I put a handwarmer inside each glove, when pull in my fingers when it gets too much.

I do not like fleece. They lose their warmth when they get wet and frozen, and they are a pain to wipe your nose on.

Nothing is perfect, you will have to find something you can live with and suffer with the rest of us.

Dennis