I grew up in Charlottesville, so I was going to recommend the Mormans (north fork). I heard that there was a flood there a few years back that did some damage. Anyone know if it's back?
I did a lot on the South, Conway, Stanton, and Rapidan -- all just a little north of town. Then there was the St. Mary's, but I understand that it's in pretty bad shape nowadays.
The Smith River down around Bassett was always a great trip too - totally different water from those little streams north of Stanardsville!
Do not tell fish stories where the people know you; but particularly, don't tell them where they know the fish. ~ Mark Twain