JC,
I have gotten two emails not meant to go to me...and I've actually clicked on the wrong icon myself and realized it was wrong.

I think with the email icon below and therefore close to the next poster's name there's a tendency to associate it with that name..the line between the posts is faint...also sometimes there's quite a space between the post and the lower icons.

It's something one certainly can get used to...but maybe not newbies.

Just a heads up ...maybe there's an easy fix...