I'm with Jed, clousers and decievers. There's no baitfish hatch that i have not been able to match with a clouser or a deciever. Sometimes you may find them feeding in a crap hatch or a worm hatch, in that case keep a couple of those around. Also, when your in a bluefish frenzy, poppers and gurglers will do the trick.

Good Luck,

Chris