Will a Castwell knot......

[Whitewolf]

Will the Castwell knot work and be sufficient to tie the tippet to the tippet ring of a furled leader?

[JohnScott]

Jim -

I'm a big fan of the Castwell knot for attaching lines to backing and leaders - the only knot for those applications that I have used for well over fifteen years now.

It has never occurred to me to try using it to attach tippet to a tippet ring. But I don't believe it will work. I think the Castwell knot works with flexible materials because it closes the materials to each other tightly and securely. I don't think that you can get that effect trying to tie a flexible material - the tippet - to an open, solid object like a tippet ring.

But - maybe it would work. I'd certainly be interested in what others think or have experienced, but a simple ( not improved ) clinch knot has always worked well for me for attaching tippet to a tippet ring, and the simple clinch knot is easier to tie than the Castwell, so I wouldn't be at all inclined to change even if the Castwell is an option.

John

[Whitewolf]

Thank you John. I tend to go along with your thoughts. The Castwell knot is indeed closing up on boaf flexible lines....not a hard ring.
Didn't think of that....well I think I sort of did because I had my doubts and asked.
I just purchased and received a Knot Kneedle tool. I think it will be good for knots.
Thank you John

[Ron Eagle Elk]

I just use a clinch know to secure tippet to a tippet ring. Been doing that for decades now.

[Tig]

There are better options for attaching a ring to a furled leader than clinch knot which by the way I use all the time for most other applications.
Do a search on this site for Attaching rings to furled leaders." Sorry I don't know how to create a link. This method in my opinion is even stronger
and easier than building the ring into the furling process.

[ohiotuber]

Thank you John. I tend to go along with your thoughts. The Castwell knot is indeed closing up on boaf flexible lines....not a hard ring.
Didn't think of that....well I think I sort of did because I had my doubts and asked.
I just purchased and received a Knot Kneedle tool. I think it will be good for knots.
Thank you John

I have the Knot Kneedle & LOVE it!...So does my 87 year old fishin' buddy. There's nothing close when tying clinch & improved clinch knots.
You made a great purchase. (just my opinion)

Mike

[Whitewolf]

Does anybody use Captain J's knot tool?....any opinions?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ursFM-bnwvU