Loop vs Split Loop?

[fritz]

When is it preferable to use loop vs split loop for hackling? Thanks

[ScottP]

If I’m using deer hair for hackle, I like a heavily waxed loop; I get better grip on the hair than if I use split thread.

Regards,
Scott

[john52948]

i use uni thread, and it does not lend itself well to a split loop scenario. I have tried to use some of the twisted fiber threads in order to enable me to use a split loop approach, but always end up fraying the thread and get a big booger when I try to whip finish the fly, so I use the loop approach and do not have a bulky head on the fly ,down to size 20. don't tie anything smaller than a 20 because I cant see it

[Beaver]

I like to use a split thread for things like CDC collars or small dubbing balls. I will use a dubbing loop for larger amounts of dubbing and larger amounts of material.

[johnstoeckel]

Split thread works best for small flies and fine applications where you want less bulk. However, split thread doesn't work with some threads -- Uni mentioned previously and I believe Danville. It's also more difficult (at least for me) and not really necessary for most applications. I use a loop quite a bit for buggy nymphs #16 or larger.