I've found the yarn indicators too heavy and catch too much air; they really seem to mess up my casting. I like the Thingamabobbers for visibility and floating a wet, but I have to use the jam stops to keep them where I want them and I don't like the way they leave kinks in my leaders. Seems like the little rubber thingies in the twist-on ones get weak and I end up seeing them floating off by themselves. The few times I've tried the stick on ones they didn't seem to work that well for me. Any suggestions? Or am I just too hard to please ?