I don't bait fish, spin fish, Ice fish. Just fly rod ...S Reel...S and a bunch different type Fly Line...S. I guide, I catch fish, I use FLY jig hooks, and BOBBERS. Never touch bait, smelly jelly of any kind.....I AM A FLY FISHER. No two ways about it. My choice, nothing wrong with other choices, just not for me.
I also don't over analyze FISHING. It is what it is. OH, I also use Glow Bugs, SJW, and Fake Fingernail Flies.....still a fly fisher.

The great thing about the Crawfish pattern I posted is the arms are rubber and the claw is foam. Great action!