A curious question
I was reading the interview with CM Stewart and Jason Klass and how Chris has gone to Japan a few times on business and all. It made me wonder how much does being interested in things Japanese have to do with being interested in tenkara? I admit I love certain things about that culture and when I found out about tenkara's Japanese origin that made it all the better. So the question is how much did tenkara being japanese have to do with getting started in tenkara?
What really persuaded me to give Tenkara style fly fishing a try was reading Ryan Jordan's article on Big River Fly Fishing and Why Tenkara Beats Western Fly Fishing Methods. Here is a link to that piece for those who have not seen or read it: http://ryanjordan.com/blog/2011/05/b...stern-methods/ Not that I have all that many big rivers to fish in my area, but primarily because I believed Tenkara tackle would work even better on the small streams that I fish than it does on the bigger rivers, and also because I believed Tenkara tackle would offer similar advantages on some of the high lakes that I love to fish so much. Which in both cases has proven to be truer than I could ever have imagined or thought it would be. Some of my best friends happen to be of Japanese descent, but for me Tenkara fly fishing's Japanese origins had nothing at all to do with my taking up this Japanese form of fly fishing in the first place.
As a matter of fact my Japanese friends have so far refused to give Tenkara fly fishing a try, even though I have offered many times to take them up fishing and provide all the tackle they would need in order to try it. I gave Wes a copy of Kevin Kelleher's Tenkara, Radically Simple, Ultralight Fly Fishing, for Christmas this year. Not because I am trying to convert him into being a Tenkara fly fisherman, but because I thought he would enjoy reading about his Japanese fly fishing heritage, and because he has a young nephew who he would like to teach fly fishing to. Tenkara fly fishing would be much easier for any youngster to pickup than Western fly fishing is in my, and many other people's, views. Wess's main love in life is fishing for steelhead. We did some Tenkara casting in my backyard about a year ago and he liked it, but he felt that Western tackle was superior for the kind of fishing he most enjoys doing the most. Many years ago I took Wes to the small mountain stream where he caught his first trout on a fly, and he does still trout fish on a much larger local river. But once he became addicted to catching striped bass, steelhead and shad, his days of fishing mountain water were over. And rightly so, Wes does not feel that Tenkara tackle offers much for him in angling for those fish.
Last edited by Golden; 12-23-2013 at 06:35 PM.
Jason didn't want to start the interview the same way all of them seem to start "So, how did you first learn about tenkara?"
For me, the fact that tenkara is Japanese really had nothing to do with it. I guess I'd have to go back to the first time I saw a photo of a North Country wet fly on the internet. The North Country style is called that because it was the style of northern England.
I was struck by the sparseness and the almost austere beauty. I wanted to learn as much as I could about them and how to fish them. I soon learned that when they originated, people used very long rods. The rods were called loop rods because they had a loop of twisted horsehair at the rod tip, and the line (also horsehair) was tied to the loop. There is a good book called The Angler and the Loop Rod, which you can read online, but there isn't really much else specifically about loop rods. I first came across a mention of tenkara while researching the horsehair lines that were used with loop rods. It turns out that the ancient tenkara anglers also used horsehair lines.
I soon learned that tenkara rods were about the length of the old loop rods, so you could fish the North Country wets they way the were originally fished. However, the rods are not only lighter and more convenient to transport, best of all they are commercially available so I wouldn't have to find someone's woodshop to try to make a loop rod. I started researching tenkara. Back then (2007), there was virtually nothing about tenkara except for Japanese websites. A few of those were in English, but most were in Japanese and the computerized translation is almost useless. That made learning anything pretty difficult.
I know a lot of people are attracted to tenkara because it is Japanese, whether because they like Japanese culture or are attracted to Zen or perhaps martial arts. To me, though, now that I've learned a bit more about it, what continues to attract me to tenkara is its effectiveness. I catch a lot more fish than I did before. The reason for that is the long rod and light line allow me to keep the line off the water, so there is less drag. Less drag means better presentation and that means more fish. Tenkara doesn't catch more fish because it's Japanese, it catches more fish because it gives you better presentations.
I really believe the Japanese origin helped to create interest in tenkara in the US, but I also believe that at least in the US, tenkara has to grow past its origins. Although interest is growing, a backlash is also growing among people who are put off by a perception of elitism or hype or a cult-like bashing of western syle fly fishing. To avoid creating a greater backlash, I think tenkara has to be presented as just another niche within the larger sphere of fly fishing, and one that has advantages in specific applications. Whether the method is Japanese or Italian or Macedonian isn't important.
I have to admit it was the flys that got me going as well. I kept studying them and how they where made. Simple yet beautiful. After that I figured i have to give them a try on an actual tenkara rod, but how would it work in warm water. Turns out it works very well flys and all. Thanks yall for the response.
For me, it doesn't matter at all that it's from Japan. I would like it same if it came from France, Switzerland, or the USA for that matter. I just like the method. But, I also happen to like Japan so as HOSSCOOPER said, that just makes it better.
I find it to be fun. Also found that it works with many flies that are brought in just under the surface.