Actually, I've always tied the 'Muddler Minnow' as it appears in the Family Circle Guide(wherein it states that it can be fished as a dry, wet or streamer, unweighted or weighted) and in the Pattern Guide by Eric Leiser. I'm not familiar the patterns by Mathews, Humphries or any other published author. And I am talking about the 'Muddler Minnow', not a 'dry muddler' or a 'muddler anything else'.