I've had an Orvis Battenkill for about 20 years. For many years it was my everyday small stream trout reel and it made a few trips to larger western rivers. They are light, durable and trouble-free in my experience. I don't use mine very much any more, but I think they would be a great choice for small stream trout fishing. If long runs aren't a factor, there isn't as much value in a disk drag and you'll get a lighter reel for less money.