This weekend I had an opportunity to cast/use some 1 thru 3 wt fly rods. Using the 2 wt., I happened to catch a palm sized gill. The rod bent almost double. The gill got caught in some weeds and it took almost 2 minutes to land. SO, what's the point of using these " wet noodle" rods ?? Is it the thrill of fighting and tiring the fish? Just WHAT is the PRACTICAL reason for using these low weight rods?
After using the lightweights, I strung up my 5 wt. It cast better, retrieved the catch quicker and frankly gave me a feel for the fishing experience unlike the lower weights.
My question should not be deemed controversial but just expressing curiosity for the choice of these rods. Is there a good reason to use a 1 wt in waters that have 16 inch trout??

Mark