" They also wanted $132 for the repairs and $50 for shipping."

I get your dismay, but:

You have no claim to the original owner warranty.

$132.00 for a new tip ( 1/4 of your rod ) on a four piece rod that went for what? I'm guessing, Six or Seven hundred and some change new. If that's so, then the $132 is far less than a quarter of it's retail price and the rods not worth diddlysquat without a tip. So I'd say they did you a big favor.

If it makes you feel any better, before any of these new warranty policies came about. " I Broke " a top shelf rod that I purchased new, made by one of the big three American rod companies. That was in the eighties and they charged more for that section - than Winston just charged you. I was thrilled to have my rod back in working order.

Now the $50.00 - What ever they want to name it fee ( S&H or Warranty Activation, etc. ). Fly rod consumers only seem to raise a fuss about this, when they have to pay it. Now if they'd just stop buying rods from companies who insist on higher fees, I guarantee they'd stop charging them. They'd just tack it on to the front side of a new rods price tag.
But that's a topic for another thread.

Dave