Frank,

I am not aware of anyone who has done any scientific studies on the differences in popper material sounds, but logic would imply that if we hear them differently, the fish would too, if their 'hearing' is anything like ours. In either case, the waves thru the medium (air or water) are different in length as can be judged by the sound we hear. The difference is probably not equal, due to the density differences, however, so the difference in 'sound' is probably not as drastic.

The only ones who could really tell us for sure are the fish, and last I checked, they ain't talking.

What's the point of even having a bulletin board if not for us, who are really just making educated guesses, to discuss what we have observed, what we feel we know, and what deductions we have made.

After all, 90% of the lures out there are more to cacth the fisherman than the fish anyway.


(Oh, and 63.8% of all statistics are made up on the spot. )