Wow...some really good posts here...

It seems to me that if you post without a recipe you :

May be posting for adulation...
You may not know that the classy thing to do would be to post a recipe..
Or you just didn't know any better...

And it really isn't too hard to ask for a recipe...I don't remember when one was asked for that it wasn't provided...
having said that put me in the camp of ...GIVE A RECIPE....