Loved the replies; just as expected. NJTroutbum gets the prize for common sense and clarity.
Short, lightweight rod with 3X tippet (direct contact with the fish) or, long rod 5-6 wt. in today's stiff, "I can cast 300' materials", with whispy 6-7X tippet.
Which gives you better leverage?
Which allows quick landing? I'm talking 30-45 seconds here, not 5 minutes or more!

I don't hurt fish; I crawl all over the spinners and pluggers and "fly experts" that do in my presense and, I have a ton of fun fly fishing.