It's funny, you look at a post like that and all of a sudden the Fish cat's and Super Fat Cats and others get mentioned when the guy asks specifically for a Scadden tube. My brother has an H3 and I've used it numerous times. I like the large cargo area in back and it does float pretty good and it has low wind resistance. I do feel more safe in it than I did when I owned a SFC. In that thing, I almost felt like I was falling forward whenever I'd bring in a fish. I'm 6'2 and 230 and I like the size of the H3. It's more comfortable too than the SFC I had. But that's just my analysis.