Yeah, that's pretty much me (troutwise). EXCEPT:
I was fishing the headwaters of the Brodhead in the Poconos. 2 years in a row, the exact same stretch of water, same time of the year- mid May, same weather conditions- light rain, same hatch- March Brown, same fly-MB Comparadun, same fly rod-7'6" 3 wt. Both times I caught (and released) 30-some trout! 3 or 4 were about 15," all over 7," all wild brownies (majority) and brookies.
The first time all of the fish were caught on the same fly. Considering my casting skills and the mountain laurel and brush lining the stream, I considered it a veritable miracle! I still have that fly!
John