The first one looks like a rebranded Columbia Frazier. I have one of those. Had it about 7 years actually. Hardly used the last 5-6 years as it's just too hot for most of my fishing. But it is a good raincoat.
Like the guys said; save up the bucks and keep your eye on the sales. I had a Cabela's $149 jacket that I had to return. Two trips in heavy rain and soaked to the skin. I got an Orvis on sale and so far it has kept me dry! And comfortable. Plus they have a great warranty.
Good luck w/your decision.