John,
I ran across Sugar Creek through a blog site by a SMB fisherman. He mentioned Shades State Park. I have a book called "Unexpected Indiana" (University of Indiana Press) and sure enough Shades was in there along with about two dozzen other places in Indiana that just could not be in Indiana, Shades & Sugar Creek among them. Most of the places shown had what looked like really good water; in Indiana. Since we were in Indy over the holiday weekend that made it close enough to take a look and see if we should try under better stream conditions. The area is very nice so we will go back and give it another try. If you want to see what you missed back home in Indiana, look for a copy of the book!
Joe