Quote Originally Posted by khao-sok View Post
Hi guys,

Being an avid paddler for over 32 years and being in the business for 16 of those years, I'd always opt for a proper sit-inside kayak, like the Tribal (Tribalance). BTW, I currently own 42 kayaks, all decked traditional models, and one gorgeous wood strip canoe.

The 'expandable' kayak looks like something that would break rather easily. Plus, I question to stability of that set-up vs the time-tested outrigger set-up.

Wide flatter boats are more stable, but slower. You need to determine your priorities and choose a boat that best suits the type of water you'll be paddling. If the types of water you plan on paddling vary, I'd go with a stronger traditional decked kayak as they are faster than most commercial sit-on-tops and a lot more efficient. Sit-on-tops are not safer. Learn how to paddle and self-rescue a real kayak and you'll be glad you made that choice... or, go for a canoe.

Plus, it doesn't take long to feel comfortable fly fishing from a seated position.

That's my humble opinion anyway.

Opinions are like ...
I would never opt for a traditional sit-inside kayak for my waters. Not practical. Sit-on-tops are the way to go.

While I do not own a Freedom Hawk, I can tell you that they are well-made and there's little chance of it falling apart or breaking.

You can certainly add outriggers or opt for something like a Freedom Hawk.

I agree that prospective kayakers should paddle different models and determine what's best for them.

Casting from the seated position isn't a problem and all and that's not the reason for standing up. We stand up to "sight-fish," which can be rather difficult (impossible?) while sitting down.