I'm pretty sure that something like this is already underway. I was discussing this same concept with someone not to long ago at a show...a field review for all gear not just rods (which I agree are difficult to compare), by pretty much anyone who wants to submit it. His main concern was getting people to put out reports. I am supposed to get a link at some point, and will keep everyone updated. Its a pretty cool concept though...kind of like the reviews on amazon, except for fly gear.