This is a great line of conversation. I venture out with a 5WT and an 8Wt. I generally chase BGs with my 5WT but when I see a Big Bass I bring up the 8Wt.

I have lost many bass on the 5WT because I could not control the fish. With the 8WT I have been able to land more fish and cast further.

I guess it is just a matter of what works for you. I guess I could also do do it with a 6WT or 7WT. But I was following Whitlock's recommendation and thought I could also use it in the Salt.

Once again great comments.