I can relate to the gent in Alaska. I too have a very old set up that was my fathers. Probably dates to later 40's/early 50's. Shakespear rod and automatic reel. He taught me how to fly fish with this set up, then handed it down to me. It still casts and catchs fish with no problem and I dont have any inclination to get another one unless this one breaks. I did buy new outfit for my son, was on the economical side (abaout $150 for rod and reel) and he is tickled everytime he uses it. I agree that fish dont care what your using, how expensive it is, what it is made of etc..., the best part is catching an elusive fish with some line, feathers, dubbing, etc.. and having a fun time doing it. Sure it would be nice to boast of having a G-loomis, etc.. but for what reason? Use what is best for you at the time, if you NEED to upgrade, then by all means do so.