I have a GLoomis Adventure 5, and the Orvis Batenkill Mid-Arbor. I like the Orvis a little better, and it is probably worth the extra $30. The build quality is definitely better than the Loomis. I agree with oldfrat that you will probably pick according to what you like in the appearance of the reel. The performance of most reels in your price range are probably close to one another. Go with the one that appeals to you!