To understand women would require us to be devine.
Lefty Kreh said something to the effect "If a flyrod cost more than $100 it is probably better than the person using it."
Printable View
There is a second hand store on South Federal here that is that way. He had an old Orvis that was pristine and priced appropriately. He also had several old Jap rods that were not even complete that he was trying to get similar money out of. He threw me out of the store, literally, when I offered him what they were worth.
Bamboo rods are just fishing rods, as are fiberglass, graphite, and the most early wooden rods.
There are good tapers and awful tapers within all these fibers. And, in my opinion, a finely executed bamboo rod trumps all others.
This is my opinion and I'm sure you have yours.
The worst, in my experience, are truly awful bamboo rods.
The Japanese post-war bamboo rods rank at the top of the list of godawful fishing tools.
I suppose they are okay if they are lightly fished for panfish? But, why would you? Just to say you're fishing bamboo? The few I've cast are literally junk as fly fishing tools. The hardware on these rods is the cheapest possible.
The bamboo itself is something dredged from the Japanese outback. All in all it is a combination of the cheapest components imaginable.
The tapers are teeth-gritting.
I truly don't know where the perception evolved that a good bamboo rod must cost thousands of dollars.
That is not the case!
There are several fine bamboo tapers that are affordable to most fly fishermen if they really want to fish bamboo.
Just my thoughts on these cheaply made Japanese rods.
Please don't waste your money on these, speaking gratuitously, rods.
Well, good for him. I'll remember to always count myself as the exception to the rule when it doesn't meet my self-proclaimed criteria.
I'm also glad you got the TFO for under a $100.00.
There are several models that I believe sell for more than that?
Casting is casting, catching fish is another thing entirely.
A few years ago I got a call from the owner of a local fly shop. A customer had brought in one of those 'box set' Japaneese cane rods. The customer wanted to have it 'redone' (rewrapped and refinished), so the proprieter wanted to know if I would undertake the job.
I stopped by to look at it, and it was truly a piece of crap. I told him it wasn't worth the work, but apparently the customer insisted. I was paid over $300 to refurbish a rod you can buy in decent condition at a garage sale for five bucks.
Came out nicely. Rod didn't cast worth a hoot, but it sure was pretty. I even refinished the wooden box it came in.
When I delivered it, I got 'the rest of the story'.
Owner was an attorney. Rod was in his attic. He didn't know where it came from, but he thought it was brought back from overseas by an uncle in the 50s. He had a wealthy client who was a fly fisherman. He wanted to give him a 'nice gift' and thought this would be 'special'.
I showed him the rod, explained what all I had done, took my check, and bought some tying materials....
Never did hear how the 'client' liked the rod....
Buddy
That's a great story Buddy!
Bob
Think some of you guys have to remember these rods are now 50 yrs old. Do not think they will stand comparison to todays stuff. Hardy & Orvis they are not.
Yes they are cheap but when you are a boy of 15yrs with no income other than a paper round it was like winning the lottery getting this old "boo"
Many a little stream Trout fell it till I got something better. I have no regrets about using it.
Did not do me any harm, if fact probably made me appreciate my gear when I got better tackle.
Tight Lines