Mark,
My wife and I stayed there 3 years ago. We ( by your description) luckily passed on the "all inclusive" option opting to use Gates Lodge's restaurant. This dude hasn't a clue as to what is at least basically needeed to attract new and returning guests. AND, my description of our experience there is NOT exxagerated. We did have holes (larger) under the carpet and the place does look like Sanford and Son's place. I think we'll stay in town where the Savages ( yes, wild folks :)) stay.
Mark