-
I had the same thing happen to me last year at a local lake they stock trout in during the winter months. Last year people were catching LMB and Crappie while fishing for Trout! I've fished this lake for trout for several years and this was the first time that I saw other species being taken on trout tackle. Fly fishing or otherwise.
Fish Are Weird!
-
Try fishing shallower in the water column, but still slowly. Since the food sources are very limited in smal ponds there will always be some fish that are moving around, slowly, looking for food.
Rick